Monday, March 17, 2014

Dilma faces turmoils as election agenda gains the media

Agência Brasil
President Dilma inducted six ministers this Monday,
two of them were nominated to make amends with PMDB
From now on no news on the politics section is unrelated with the election for presidents, governors, deputies and senators on october. Every announcement, every quote from a political personality has now a direct reference to the dispute between Dilma and so far the two other possible candidates (Eduardo Campos from PSB and Aécio Neves from PSDB).

The electoral tone was all over two stories that represented a downturn to Dilma on the last couple of weeks: the mess in the energy sector and the dispute with PMDB, the major allied party of Dilma. In the first case, Rui Falcão, president of PT (Worker's Party, the PT of Dilma) declared that PMDB was only interested in positions in the government and not as much in reaching the greater good for the country. Eduardo Cunha, the leading deputy of PMDB in the Congress started a rebellion and threatened to go against some of the most important projects of the government such as the Marco Civil da Internet (the Civil Landmark of the Internet -- a set of rules for the internet business in the country), due to be voted this week.

Initially Dilma tried to ignore the opposition inside her own allied base. But after realizing the power of the unpleased allies she decided to nominate two of PMDB approved names for the ministrers of Agriculture and Tourism. Ironically the crisis that started with a critic of the PMDB greediness for positions inside the government is being solved by providing PMDB with positions in the government.

Another setback for Dilma was in the energy area. Briefly put, the government decided to anticipate the end of some of the energy contracts last year (this way provoking a cut in the energy prices for the end consumer, that would represent a discount of 28% for residential users). The project backfired as it stimulated energy consumption in a time of the year where the hydroelectric dams were not getting as much rain as in the previous years. This forced the electric system to turn on the thermoelectric plants that are more expensive. In order to keep its promise of a cheaper energy, the government decided to subsidize the energy bill by putting billions to pay the extra cost of thermoelectric energy. After denying for several weeks that that was a crisis in the sector, the government decided to acknowledge the problem and promised to not interfere in future contracts at the same time it waved with a tax increase to cover the future costs of the more expensive energy. It was one perfect example of how not to manage a country, given by a president that sold an image of a great manager in the energy department.

Both situations show how bad the current government, and I would dare to say the current president, deal with this sort of conflicts. When faced with a situation where there is a need for negotiation the government usually try to impose itself first and end up being obliged to step back and offer a much more costly and inefficient solution in the end.

Monday, March 10, 2014

Street-sweepers' strike and racism in Brazil

One of the most relevant news in this year's Carnival was the street-sweepers strike in Rio de Janeiro. Even after the union of street-sweepers reached a deal with the city hall in the middle of the celebration, part of the workers disagreed and refused to clean the streets, as millions danced samba and produced tons of garbage.

The dissident workers said the union leaders were not looking for their peers best interest and decided to continue with the strike. After eight days, they conquered a 37% increase in their salary on a meeting with the city government on saturday (March 8th), a much better result than the 9% the
union agreed on monday (March 3rd).

The episode shows two sides of the Brazil's social inequality. First, the vulnerable representation such workers have. The difference between the salary raise the union leaders agreed upon (9%) and the final result after the dissidents protests (37%) shows how union leaders and politicians worked in collusion against the street-sweepers best interest.

Reproduction
On top, doctors (mostly white) protest
against the government last yer.
Below: street-sweepers (mostly black)
on strike in Rio
The second aspect relates to the racial inequalities in the country. The street-sweepers strike showed clearly a vast majority of  black workers. This contrasts with the predominance of white doctors that protested last year against the government, against the program that import physicians from Cuba and other foreign countries. The striking difference of the images was shared this past week in social media, reminding one of the hidden faces of the Brazilian racism, that is usually hidden under social inequalities.

Next week I'll come back to the business, financial and political commentaries. For the time being, it worths saying in this matter that Dilma Rousseff is dealing with a rebellion from her allies. The biggest party that composes the situation coalition, PMDB, is threatening to retreat its support after the Rui Falcão, president of the Workers' Party (PT, Dilma's party), said during the Carnival that all that PMDB's members want are more ministries and government positions. The real reasons for PMDB moves are abundant and for sure are not related solely to Falcão's declaration -- hopefully I'll be able to address some of them here next week. For now, both parties are now trying to mend the alliance that will be crucial in this election year.

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

World Cup: 100 days to go

This tuesday marked the 100 day countdown to the 2014 World Cup. It is really an interesting coincidence that this event that fueled the protests of last year reaches this symbolic milestone now, as millions of people are occupying the streets of Brazil -- just this time for a different reason: to celebrate the Carnival. 

[If the tranquility of the Carnival mass celebration, in clear opposition to the violence of the protests, may strike you as a contradiction bear in mind two things. First  the Carnival is a people's party, so it may be seen as opposed to the opulent stadiums built for the benefit of a few. Another hypothesis is that the Carnival is the moment when the "silent majority" that actually disapproves violence in the protests (as seen through the Data Folha survey) actually comes to the street. These are at least two reasons I could think of.]

Agência Brasil
In Rio, millions celebrated the Carnival,
that had no reports of protests
Both O Globo and Folha de S. Paulo dedicated different stories to the landmark towards the World Cup. Just O Globo put with all the letters that the event is dividing the country. In a beautifully written article published on the sports section, the newspaper interviews two former players from the Brazil football (I'll always mean soccer by that) team with distinct visions of the World Cup and its meanings. The text start by saying that so far the sole legacy from the event are the protests and calls this 100 days journey as a journey to self discovery. 

Folha decided to approach the event with a different strategy. In the Economics section, the newspaper talked about the inflated prices in hotel rooms and how they are driving an increase in temporary rents from people that own houses near the stadiums that will host the event -- an american tourist paid US$ 1,640 for renting a three bedroom apartment near the stadium of Porto Alegre, more than what could be earned in a whole month in the area. In another related article it also says that the hotels in the cities that are just serving as training sites for the football teams are not receiving much reservation from tourists. 

The controversial part of the tournament was raised by the OpEd section in an article signed by Ronaldo Nazario (Ronaldinho), a member of the committee in charge of organizing the World Cup. The former Brazil forward plays defense on the text, saying the US$ 3.4 billion investment on the stadiums since 2007 were not much compared to the  US$ 323 billion spent on health care in the same period. "Brazil is progressing a lot, in social and economical terms, and has been correcting the inequalities in the recent years. We need to keep pursuing a better country. This final is played every two years in october and not in july", says Ronaldo calling protesters to express their dissatisfaction in the ballots and not inside or outside the stadiums.

Monday, February 24, 2014

Dilma is still ahead in election poll

Even with all the protests, president Dilma would be elected in the first round of the presidential elections this year, according to the latest survey from Datafolha published this sunday. Dilma ranks first with 43% to 47% of the votes in different scenarios with different competitors, making more than the sum of all the other candidates for president. The result points to a stable perspective from the last evaluation of Dilma electoral performance and according to Folha analysis means that it is Dilma that should run as a candidate for PT (the Worker's Party) and not former president Lula. This was received as good news to the government because it shows that president Dilma's popularity recovered from the past results on october lat year when her vote intention was in 42%.

Agência Brasil
Dilma will face the challenge of keeping the economy
growing while avoiding inflation
In spite of the good numbers, Dilma still has some challenges ahead. Her negative evaluation went up from the previous survey, showing that her current popularity might fall in the future. The risks with the economy downturn (with the current strategy from the Central Bank to reduce the economic growth in order to control inflation) and the possible negative impacts of protests in the World Cup may force a second round of the elections in the end of October.

Former president Fernando Henrique Cardoso, from the social democrat party (PSDB), the biggest rival of PT, bets against Dilma in an interview published this weekend in El País Brasil, given to my former  boss Carla Jimenez and to Luis Prados. Cardoso makes an interesting diagnosis of the current state of affairs in Brazil: PT has lost the momentum to carry on the reforms when the country faced a window of opportunity -- as a matter of fact, the government never saw it as a window of opportunity but rather as a permanent state that, as we all know, already passed. He says, though, that if it was not the case that the country was as good as international investors thought it was in the past, it is not as bad as they think now. He claims we need a better positioning in Latin American politics (which now has an all new economic bloc: the Pacific Alliance) and expects the current dissatisfaction now common in the middle class and businessmen will be also passed on to the greater part of the population as the campaign goes on.

Protests
Enough with politics. Now back to the protests. This weekend a new set of protests against the World Cup and now the new wave of hikes in the bus tariff (that should happen in all major capitals by the end of the year) has again ended in violence. This time the controversial attitudes came out of São Paulo police and its new "ninja force"(policemen that know their ways in martial arts, and carry no guns) when they started to arrest and remove protesters based only in suspicions -- this was criticized by some lawyers because it would go against Brazilian Constitution that only allows police to act based on facts. Five journalists were taken down by these same policemen, carried out of the protests and later let go when the Police chief found out they were working to cover the protests. Among them was my former O Globo colleague and friend, Sergio Roxo. Interesting enough, as Roxo wrote in O Globo, the the protest in São Paulo ended with 6 injured people, among them 4 cops, one of which broke his arm while trying to immobilize a protester.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

Press versus Black Blocs

Since the protests started on june 2013, the press has been a target of some of the revolted young people. Last week, after the journalist from TV Bandeirantes, Santiago Andrade, died on consequence of a firework explosion detonated by one of the Black Bloc protesters, this confront was more than evident. On one side we had still some of the same voices (that supported the violence of Black Blocs from the beginning) trying to downsize the meaning of the death, at the same time we had somewhat an overreaction on part of the media.

Before going further on this issue it is necessary to clarify somethings. The press has always been in the radar of leftist movement's critic in Brazil. And it is not without any reason: part of Brazilian press supported the military cup of 1964 (namely through the work of a liberal journalist called Carlos Lacerda, that latter turned against the regime) and a greater part just omitted the critic to the regime in order to keep running. Globo Television is seeing as a member of the later, especially after they called a immense manifestation for the direct presidential election as a commemoration of the city of São Paulo's anniversary. 

reproduction
This is on the roots of the anger against the media. At almost all the manifestations and protests I covered at some point I could hear protesters shouting: "Fora Rede Globo, o povo não é bobo"(something like "Go away Globo Network, people are not stupid"). Not surprisingly protesters attacked reporters from day one, but maybe because the violence coming from the police was bigger (with a photographer losing the vision of one of his eyes due to a rubber bullet), the press focused its attention to the violence from the police. Latter, namely in Rio, O Globo started covering more closely the actions of Black Blocks that managed to remove the multitudes of protesters from the streets through their violence (the phrase if from a musical producer from Rio, I just borrowed). 

This week main TV news shows devoted a lot of time to give a proper dimension of Santiago's death, and ask for Justice (16 minutes in Jornal Nacional, of Globo TV, and 15 minutes in the Jornal da Band, of the Bandeirantes television, where Santiago worked). The two young Black Blocs responsible for the death were quickly arrested, in Brasilia, deputies were quick in drafting laws against protests, from an intelligent one that typifies the crime of disorder (allowing the police to actually remove people with rocks and dangerous behaviors from the protests, something they couldn't do due to a gap in legislation) to extremely dangerous ones, such as the one that relates protests to terrorist activity. 

That's not part of the overreaction, yet. For me, the overreaction came with the attempt of putting the decentralized group of the Black Blocs as part of a leftist movement aimed to create chaos on the verge of the World Cup. Newspapers quickly assumed, basing on vague an unconfirmed declarations, that the Black Blocs were connected to PSOL (a leftist party, that is very active in the protests) and quickly connected them with a Rio deputy, Marcelo Freixo.

The press steps back
Today, on their sunday edition, both Folha de S. Paulo, and part of O Globo, acknowledge part of the overreaction, which is a good thing. Folha devotes a full page to understand the movements behind the protests, and differentiate leftist, anarchist and other independent social movements from the Black Blocs. Folha also ran a survey in Rio that shows that more than 70% of the people still supports the protests, event almost 100% (I believe 98% or so) are against any act of violence from protesters and the police. Stories about the need to train better the police also were published during the week, which is also aiming to the correct direction.

The impression I get, looking from a big distance, is that finally the Black Bloc has lost its momentum. The group seduced part of young people that don't see any chance of manifesting themselves in the country's democracy, as correctly pointed out Vladimir Safatle, on Globo News this week. It is not the case that the country has no means of participating, we actually have a lot of institutionalized ways of participating, but they are opaque to the vast majority of the population. In the roots of this problem is the traditional lack of political participation among the whole population and the huge disbelief in the political parties (a disbelief that is more or less occurring also in developed countries). 

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Some ponderations

Reprodução Twitter
Ramona Rodriguez, cuban doctor asked for
political refuge in Brazil this week
There are two things that upset me about the media and social media coverage in Brazil. On the one hand, mainstream media often is too critical and lacks a bit of context on the government decision. This, on the other hand, leads people on social media to call the whole media conservatives and fuel protesters to physically harm journalist (as this week was seen with the TV Bandeirantes cameraman hit by a bomb).

Over the past two weeks I've seen examples on both sides of this sort of thing. Two weeks ago, TV show Manhattan Connection interviewed Luiza Trajano, owner of one of the biggest store chains in Brazil, Magazine Luiza. One of the journalists, Diogo Mainardi, speaking directly from Italy where he now lives, was saying Ms. Trajano that her sector was living a crisis. She repeatedly said that was not the case, but he insisted and then she showed him the actual numbers, that were showing an increase in sales at the end of last year. 

The stress of negative points on Business journalism is something the Brazilian press does more often than we think. This is why the Central Bank disregarded the press criticism when it first cut down the interest rates. At that time it was the right thing to do, and it worked. Maybe if the press weren't so over critic, the government would listen to it more often, and maybe it would avoid the current stagflation we are facing. 

The other example occurred this week. When a great set of bad news for the government rightfully gained the newspapers. Let’s start from the beginning. A blackout (I believe the third of its kind), reached most of the country on Tuesday followed by the request for political refugee from a Cuban doctor, part of the government program (one of the many inspired by Hugo Chávez, due to its political profits in terms of votes) Mais Médicos (more doctors), and the arrest of Henrique Pizzolato, former executive of Banco do Brazil and member of the Workers Party in Italy. Immediately, bloggers and government supporters went out to say that the blackout was an isolated event (it always is), that the cuban doctor is just one among 7,400 others who are doing their jobs and so on.  It's sad to see that the same flaws are repeating, and that apparently they are not seen as a problem to some supporters of the government. 

This pretty much resumes the events of the past two weeks, I wish I could have written in more depth of all of them, but time is short in this year. Hopefully from now on the weekly posting will continue. 

Sunday, January 19, 2014

A youth longing for opportunities and an economy needing more qualified workers

Captura de vídeo no  Youtube
Jefferson Luís, creator of one of the "rolezinhos" 
After reading some more about the "rolezinhos" phenomena I have to acknowledge an error in my previous post. As it seems and as some more protests in favor of the initial movements showed throughout this week, the initial events were not intentioned to raise some level of theft. They were instead just meetings from teenagers that long for more spaces of socialization, and that too like the safe and fresh environment of the country's biggest shopping centers.

It is true that Brazil's shoppings often stand out as an immense contradiction even when compared to their surroundings. Particularly on the one shopping in São Paulo (the Shopping Metro Tatuapé) that hosted one of the rolezinhos, there is a considerable contrast between the security inside and outside the building. It is one of the many contradictions that still persist in Brazil as I pointed out during this week. Today O Globo has a story about movements this time made to support the rolezinhos.

Newspapers were also not short of articles trying to understand the phenomena, listed by sociologists heard by O Globo as a protest of an apolitical youth that also want to be included in the consuming society. During the week one of the organizers from the movements, 20 year old Jefferson Luís, was interviewed by O Globo, O Estado de S. Paulo, TV Record, G1  and Vice websites. Working as a full time helper in a company on Guarulhos, on the metropolitan region of São Paulo, Jefferson is a funk singer that has 2.5 thousand Facebook followers and wanted just to have a good time with his friends in a shopping, but things got out of control.  El País Brazil also posted a nice article underlining the meaning of the rolezinhos and how poor young people in Brazil are constantly mistreated.

The three biggest Brazilian newspapers all came with different cover stories this Sunday. O Globo and O Estado de S. Paulo with more economic stories, the first bringing to attention the lack of intermediate qualified workers in Brazil which contradictory as it seems forces industries to hire more qualified technicians and graduated workers to execute simpler tasks and the second showing how the 23 billion tax benefits conceded by the Federal Government for automakers has undermined local governments to pay their expenses.

Folha de S. Paulo on the other hand explored the political side of the 2014 World Cup in yet another scandal: a 870 million reals bill that local governments payed for the event, that should, by contract, be paid by the Brazilian Fifa's subsidiary.

Country's economy will be highlighted this week
It will be the first time Dilma will attend Davos as a president. In another effort to reduce the malaise between the government and the rating agencies, the president is supposed to address markets to show the existing opportunities in investing in infrastructure in Brazil. All of this one week after Brazil's Central bank raised interest rates from 10% to 10,5% a year. It seems the government decided to be serious about the economy in the beginning of the electoral year.