Sunday, January 12, 2014

"Rolezinho" and the Maranhão prison massacre

Reproduction
Warning in Iguatemi Shopping in a high class
neighborhood: protesters will bi fined 
The past week was a reminder of the immense inequalities existent still in Brazil -- despite the recent advances in income distribution and the low unemployment in the country. In São Paulo the "rolezinhos" -- Facebook events that started being created last december by periphery teenagers set to take place in big shopping centers intended to protest, create chaos and some level of theft -- aroused a reaction from the companies. After some discussion whether it would be legal to oppress the protesters, finally the main shopping centers were granted a justice injunction that allowed them to make a security check in every visitor and also the police to curb the events and fine in 10,000 Brazilian reals whoever is joining the movement. 

In the periphery slang "rolezinho" could be translated as a small hang out, which is ironic since one of the first rolezinhos gathered more than 6 thousand people in the Itaquera Shopping in the east zone of São Paulo. For me, this phenomenon is really interesting as it points out that social media is becoming a sort of political arm also for youngsters from the periphery, and not only the middle class. 

A worst reminder of how deep and critical is the current situation occurred on tuesdeay, when Folha de S. Paulo website published a video in which  three prisoners were decapitated (the scenes are extremely violent) int the Pedrinhas prison, located in the  Maranhão state, North of Brazil. Since december, 62 prisoners were killed in the institution, mainly in protests concerning the overpopulation of the prison. 

This instantly opened up a discussion about Brazil's prison system. The federal government immediately launched a plan to move prisoners and try to revert the crisis.  This also poses a doubts  about the future alliances for the election since Maranhão is basically a feud from the Sarney family (José Sarney, a former Brazil's president,  is a senator from the neighbor Amapá State and his daughter, Roseana Sarney is currently Maranhão's governor) and José Sarney is the main leader of the biggest situation party, PMDB.We are still about to see what will come out of this.  

Sunday, January 5, 2014

2014 predictions and expectations

This year is definitely a big year for Brazil. The country will host the World Cup after 54 years, there is a presidential election coming and a lot of expectations on whether the last year protests are going to repeat or not. I wouldn't say there is a turmoil or volatile environment in the country right now. I'd put it more like a feeling that people are longing for change.


There is surely a notion now widespread that the country lost a lot of opportunities in attracting foreign investment when it was abundant and when Brazil was Latin America's darling. This feeling was long ago vented by more orthodox economists when president Dilma begun to fight the high interest rates. A fight which she has been defeated last year.

Now it seems that the pessimism is a consensus. We should not grow in 2014 more than the expected 2.3% that we should achieve in 2013. The government expenditures are likely to rise in an election year, bringing together the inflation rates. The reforms and changes long needed to attract investment and improve the education, judicial, political and health care systems will be once again delayed and we will be left with more and more demands for the next president or the next Dilma Rousseff's term in power.

The forecasts aren't necessarily gloom but neither they are exciting. It seems the country is running on auto pilot. I believe former president Fernando Henrique Cardoso, in an article for O Globo, captured the right needs for the country right now. It is mandatory that we increase productivity, that we establish new and strategic free trade treaties with countries that are recovering economically, such as the United States, and struggle to maintain Brazil's importance over South America. The Worker's Party ideology played a major role, says Cardoso, in delaying this pragmatic move towards market integration and foreign investment attraction.

I agree with that in general. Brazil is likely to be stuck in the current level of development and income if it doesn't invest in education and improve the tools for private investment. Ideology has been the worst enemy of our economic policy the last few years, this is true. There are somethings, though, that deserve consideration and contextualization.

Personally I believe that the Worker's Party experience through Lula's two consecutive terms as a president gave the impression that the government lost the chance to grow bigger, and to increase the national power of Brazilian companies. The main point at the time was the sense that during the crisis, the country bended once again to the financial markets (mostly responsible for the crisis itself) and increased the interest rates was the wrong move. I heard more than once from economists to politicians that the country, back in 2008, had lost a window of opportunity to slice interest rates to international levels.

This certainly changed with Dilma. The president aimed straight to the interest rates and had the feeling she won the battle. In 2011, the first year of decreases, inflation was kept down, and the financial system survived. There wasn't a huge increase in the families debt and the economy kept running. But when inflation eventually came, the government refused to take a step back and allow for a spike in interest rates. It rather took a different, non-conventional, path, decreasing taxes for specific sectors. This was the first "hubris" mistake I would say Dilma has learned the hardest way last year.

Another thing that changed during Dilma's office was the privatization. Since the privatization of state companies during the Fernando Henrique Cardoso term, there were a lot of opposition against the private initiative in Brazil. This is not at all unjustified. The first auctions of public goods privileged the price the companies would pay for the government instead of the price they would charge their customers for their services. This created a lot of aversion to this model of administration as winning companies charged higher fares for their services. Under the Lula's government some roads were auctioned following the exact opposite model (privileging customer's fares rather than the government prize) but this also had the inconvenience of making it difficult for companies to fulfill their investment commitments (specially under Brazilian bureaucracy) and was also rejected as a model.

Dilma had then the mission to change the model, offering the best of the two worlds: a fair price for the users of the conceded services and the guarantee that the investments were to be made. The word privatization was never again used, after Cardoso's term, and was substituted for concession, which should mean that the government would still have a regulating power and would be ultimately the owner of the public good. A lot of discussion was made on the return that the market required for the investments (considered in the beginning to high on the part of the government and too low on the part of the market). Another topic was the know-how requirement for the companies that would take part on the auctions. After first big airport concession in São Paulo, Brasília and Belo Horizonte, where some of the winners didn't have a lot of experience with busy and huge airports the rules of auctions were also changed.

Making a long story short, all of this contributed for the delays on the auctions. While there were some unpredictable things (considering that the government was also learning from the process), the ideology played also a major role here. If the government had been less tough in her first concern that private companies were demanding too much return for their investment, perhaps the auctions would have occurred during a time Brazil was still attracting foreign investment. The long discussion and the indefinition made the country fold when it had the best hand.

Both the notion that inflation should be a higher concern than low interest rates at all costs, and that there is a serious need to make the private concessions happen are in the speech of Ministry of the Presidential Chief of Staff, Minister Gleisi Hoffmann today on an interview to Folha de S. Paulo.

What to expect, then, from this very busy year? I believe there will be some building up of the Brazilian stock markets (though this is more a hope than a prediction) after the tragedy of 2013 and hopefully the World Cup will happen without major problems, but not without protests (there is a big one already scheduled for january 25th, called "No World Cup"). The doubt is over the presidential election and the next year. If the elections were today, Dilma would win. The big question in this case would be whether she would be committed more to an ideological administration than to the pragmatism that I believe is needed right now for the country.

Monday, December 16, 2013

Our "Snow Fall"?

Folha de S. Paulo launched yesterday a series of stories that try to grasp the whole magnitude of one of the most controversial infrastructure constructions in Brazil's history: the Belo Monte hydroelectric plant. That is the first example of news story that I could find in Brazilian media that is completely inspired in the Snow Fall project by the New York Times. Texts, amazing infographics and even a game help the reader to grasp the magnitude of the project that took 10 months and the work of five reporters to be completed.

Folha hasn't mentioned whether it is going to be also published as an e-book when the series of stories comes to an end, similarly to what happened to NYT's Snow Fall (the story of an avalanche on Washington state), but it is likely that the newspaper try to do that, since the both projects bare great similarity -- just compare Snow Fall's site (http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall/#/?part=tunnel-creek) with a Batalha de Belo Monte (http://arte.folha.uol.com.br/especiais/2013/12/16/belo-monte/) and see it for yourself.

In the first text, Folha is basically stating some known figures about the project, starting with the amazing dimension of what it is about to be the third biggest hydroelectric plant, after The Three Gorges Dam in China and Itaipu in Brazil. The project of the plant was initiated in 1975 and was surrounded with conflict from the beginning. Located near an indian territory, the project was changed several times, until the main reservoir was reduced considerably and an additional dam was included.

The first energy generated from Belo Monte should be delivered to Brazil domestic market in the beginning of 2015. After incredibly just 44 months of construction under the Amazon tropical weather and its implications. The engineers believe the project can have a three month delay on account of a worker's strike, local indian protests, and a stoppage determined by the court. Let's see what is reserved for the next chapters.

Sunday, December 1, 2013

The latest election survey from Datafolha

It seems that after a major setback from the bad economic news to the protests, president Dilma's popularity is on the rise again. The latest survey from Datafolha, a research company of the newspaper Folha de S. Paulo, shows that the president would be successful among any candidate that is considered today. Dilma scores from 41% to 47% of the total votes' intentions. This means that she would defeat almost all of their opponents in the first round of the presidential elections with the exception of Marina Silva, that is currently being accounted most as a vice-president candidate for the Eduardo Campos candidacy.

Behind this more favorable scene are some recent change on the news, that were more optimists on later weeks. Finally the government concessions got out of the paper, with the airports and the first road segment (of BR-163)  being delivered to the private initiative. The inflation also seemed to be under control, with the market predictions falling down on the beginning of the week and the Central Bank raising interest rates to 10%, on another sign that the economic policy is searching for more credibility. 

In this scenario, the government authorized an increase of 2% on the gasoline prices by Petrobras, that was suffering with cash flow problems since it had to import the fuel with a higher price than consumers in Brazil pay for it. It is still not enough for the company's needs, market analysts said, but it is a sign that things are changing. 

Last but not least, the recent news that the statistics bureau IGBE is revising last year's growth from 0.9% to 1.5% also contributed to the change of humor this week. Let's hope that the country keeps on this track for the next year.

Sunday, November 24, 2013

Mensalão - big politicians in jail

This past week the Brazil's superior court ordered the prison of 11 politicians, connected to the mensalão political scandal that came to public eight years ago. They are mainly from the Workers' Party, the same of president Dilma. Among the prisons there are important politics such as José Dirceu, the strong man at Lula's first term as a president.

After the final decision to order the arrests the week before, the Brazilian media was surprised at the beginning of the week with the information that one of the convicteds, Henrique Pizzolato, former director at Banco do Brazil, a state controlled bank, fled to Italy to escape the prison. He is nowon the Interpol wanted list.

Another topic about the arrests is that José Genoino, a congressman that should loose his seat after the conviction is trying a manover to avoid the scandal by asking an early retirement from congress. He also got the privilege of house arrest after stating that he had a hert condition. A medical committee is now analyzing his actual health to see if the privilege should be maitained.

From workers party supporters there was a lot of complaint against the arrests. A manifest signed by lawyers and judges was made public this week against the Supreme Court president, Joaquim Barbosa, questioning the arrest order before 48 hours after the court's final decision. Another argument used by the supporters is that the convicted politicians didn't have the option for a second instance court. This happened because there are privileges that impede politicians to be judged by a regular court in the first place. It is also one of the explanations why the case took so long to be ruled.

Today, O Globo announced that Banco do Brasil is going to seek to recover he 78 million reals that were spent in Mensalão to buy votes from congressmen between 2003 and 2005. 

The case should still be in the news during this week as the congress will vote on the loss of Genoino mandate. 

Concessions

Another important thing that took the attention of the Brazilian press was the concession of two of the most important airports to the private sector. After some protelation the airports of Confins, in Belo Horizonte, capital of the state of Minas Gerais, and Galeao, the biggest airport in Rio de Janeiro were finally passed to the private sector. Now more than half of  Brazilian passengers will use private controlled airports. The biggest winner was Odebrecht a big Brazilan contractor, that was benefited by the concession Edital that established a limit share of 15% of companies that already got the airports of Sao Paulo, Brasilia and Campinas.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Story about dictatorship crimes and photo on this year's protests are the main winners of the ExxonMobil Journalism Prize

Today the results of one of the most traditional journalism prizes in Brazil was released, the "Prêmio Esso", sponsored by ExxonMobil. The main news story prize was sent to the story about the secret files of the DOI-CODI (the department responsible for repressing people opposing the dictatorship in Brazil, that lasted from 1964 until 1985). The news story came in a very important moment in Brazil when the country is currently analyzing crimes committed during the tough period through the works of the Truth Commission (Comissão da Verdade). It worth mentioning that president Dilma herself is a victim of the dictatorship, having been tortured and arrested during the period.

Concerning that matter, the Truth Commission started today the process of exhumation of the body of former president João Goulart. Recent documents showed that the president (the last of the democratic period that preceded the dictatorship of 1964) was constantly monitored by the military. For those reasons, Goulart’s family asked in 2007 for an investigation to see if his premature death in 1976 (at the age of 57 years) supposedly from a heart attack was actually caused by poisoning.

The Prêmio Esso also recognized the picture (above) from Victor Dragonetti Tavares, that was the first one that actually put the mid year protests on the cover of the major Brazilian newspapers. The image shows a wounded cop trying to control a protester while defending himself from the crowd. The interesting thing about this picture is that it preceded the major repressing action from the police that ended with several protesters wounded. I remember clearly seeing editorials from major newspapers (I don’t recall now whether it was Folha de S. Paulo or O Estado de S. Paulo) actually calling for more police action on the protests that at that time were causing major traffic jams in São Paulo.

After that picture the police acted, but disproportionally, and images of ordinary people wounded gained the social networks and spread the protests concentrated in São Paulo and Rio to the whole country. This triggered a support for protesters that led to the government response and the reduction of the public transport fare (that were the main reasons for the initial protests).

Both stories are in the core of Brazil’s media attention right now. Today the main subject being analyzed by the press is the judgment of Mensalão (the corruption scheme denounced in 2006 during the 1st term of president Lula, that basically consisted in the purchase of congressmen votes) that involves several of the Worker’s Party (PT) important members.The corruption is clearly one of the motives of the protests. So far the news is that the supreme court maintained what was ruled before and is asking for the immediate arrest of several of the 27 convicted persons, but I’ll wait to see tomorrow’s newspapers to write more about the subject.

Monday, November 4, 2013

The general tone around Dilma Rousseff

Nobody yet knows at what extent this year’s protests will have an effect on the next year’s presidential elections. There were those who said it would impede Dilma from being reelected and I certainly believe it was one thing that gave Eduardo Campos and the its party the PSB the final push towards moving out of the government and launching a presidential candidacy for president.

One thing is for sure, the tone of the press around Dilma could certainly be one indicator that preceded the protests. Initially the press was very positive around Dilma. The president got compliments from O Estado de S. Paulo in her first interview. Dilma was somewhat protected by the press during her first year as a president, when she had to cut six ministers accused of corruption.

The honeymoon started to end throughout the second year and definitely ended in the end beginning of this year, when it became clear that the country’s economy stability had been thrown away by the president, in the name of maintaining (artificially) the unemployment low and the president’s popularity high. The main indicator that this was the case was the lost of the grip in inflation, that obliged Dilma to push back one of her main objectives in the economic policy (of bringing the Brazilian interest rates to international levels).

Today, Ricardo Noblat, columnist of O Globo, elevates even more the tone against the president, siding her with two other Brazilian contradictions already unmasked: the former senator Demóstenes Torres (that was a symbol of honesty until he was linked with Carlos Cachoeira, a criminal that run illegal gambling business across the Brazil’s center-west region) and Eike Batista (a Brazilian billionaire, featured as one of the richest men in the world, and now facing bankruptcy). Noblat says Dilma’s contradiction is her fame as a tough manager, highly promoted by Lula. Since none of the big infrastructure improvements were launched due to a lack of managerial and political abilities, Noblat says it is a big contradiction that Dilma still has a chance of being elected for a second term.

This certainly gives another glimpse of what will be the general tone against the president next year, and again can also indicate that the amount of effort, and money, that PT will have to spend for this reelection will be much more than expected two years ago.